The source and why it matters

The paper under review is van Teijlingen et al. (2024), "PhD progress and transfer vivas at universities in the United Kingdom", published in the open-access Journal of Education and Research (volume 14, issue 1, pages 104 to 116). The five authors are based at Bournemouth University and the University of Strathclyde, and the journal classifies the article as a reflective paper.
In the UK, doctoral candidates are commonly registered first on a provisional basis, often as MPhil/PhD students, and confirmed as PhD candidates only after an assessment part-way through the programme. The authors note that this milestone goes by many names, including progress viva, transfer assessment, upgrade viva, confirmation review and major review (van Teijlingen et al., 2024). Whatever it is called, it is often the first time a candidate's work is judged by academics other than the supervisors, which is why it deserves more attention than it receives.
The paper's central argument is simple: new doctoral students tend to leave the rules about progress assessment far down their list of priorities, yet those rules and the expectations of what should be produced vary between universities and even between faculties, so students should learn them early (van Teijlingen et al., 2024).
What the paper says
The authors describe the purpose of the assessment in two parts: to judge whether the student and the project are, at least potentially, of doctoral level, and whether submitting the thesis within a reasonable time is realistic. They stress that a review can identify struggling students while remedial action is still possible, and that its aim is to support and guide rather than criticise. Typically, the student submits a report, takes part in an oral examination, and independent examiners reach a decision; supervisors may attend, but often without a part in the decision (van Teijlingen et al., 2024).
Four short examples, drawn from the authors' experience as students, supervisors and assessors, show how differently the process can work.
| Example | Setting | Format described | Point the authors draw |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bournemouth University | A written document of about 3,000 words, a short presentation and two independent assessors; supervisors may attend as silent witnesses | An informal intention can sit inside formal policy language; feedback after the review matters |
| 2 | Interdisciplinary project combining philosophical, qualitative and quantitative approaches | Two assessors and a chair | Assessors who have not agreed their expectations beforehand can confuse the outcome; the student should be allowed to answer for themselves |
| 3 | Chemistry | A long report (about 22,000 words) graded on the written report, the oral examination and laboratory performance; the supervisor may attend and speak | Science projects can produce results early, so expectations differ from the humanities |
| 4 | Interdisciplinary pathway across psychology, computer science and complexity science | A 5,000-word first review at nine months and a confirmation review at 18 months | Panel expertise and supervisory support shape the outcome; a failed review was passed after supervision was restructured |
The fourth example is the most striking. The student failed the confirmation review, recalled hearing clapping from the building as they left with the news, and passed only after the supervisory team was changed. The authors use it to show how a lack of support can harm a student (van Teijlingen et al., 2024). A short historical illustration follows: in 1988, one co-author learned only after the event that a meeting with a single supervisor had been a transfer assessment, which contrasts with the more formal procedures of today.
The paper closes with fourteen recommendations for students, supervisors and universities. They range from reading the regulations and preparing properly, through resolving supervisor and student disagreements before the review and ensuring panels have relevant expertise, to providing clear written feedback, pastoral support after a poor outcome and training for assessors (van Teijlingen et al., 2024). The same team had earlier made a parallel argument about the wide variation in outcomes available at the final PhD examination (van Teijlingen et al., 2022).
Strengths
- It names a neglected milestone. Research on doctoral assessment concentrates on the final thesis and viva (Mullins & Kiley, 2002). Bringing the mid-point review into view is useful in itself.
- It makes variation concrete. The examples show differences in timing, length, panel composition and the supervisor's role that a single university's handbook never reveals.
- It speaks to all three audiences. The recommendations are addressed separately to students, supervisors and institutions, so each reader can see what is within their control.
- It takes the emotional side seriously. The paper treats the review as an event that can affect confidence and identity, not only as a procedure, which is consistent with evidence that doctoral students face a substantial risk of psychological distress (Levecque et al., 2017).
Limitations and methodological issues
The paper is honest about what it is: a reflective account, not an empirical study. That is a legitimate genre, but it shapes how far its claims can be taken.
- No stated method. The paper does not explain how the four examples were chosen, whose experiences they record, or whether the students involved consented to their stories being published. For a reader this matters less for credibility than for transparency: we cannot tell how typical the examples are.
- Selective lens. Most examples come from the authors' own institutions and networks. Variation is shown, but its extent across the sector is not measured.
- No outcome data. The recommendations are plausible, but none is tested. Whether, for example, assessor training or written feedback changes completion or wellbeing is not examined.
- Light engagement with theory. The paper cites relevant studies but does not draw on assessment theory, such as the distinction between formative and summative purposes, to explain why the same event can feel supportive in one setting and threatening in another.
The authors themselves observe that, like the final viva, the progress review is socially constructed: personalities and interpretations of the rules play a part, so the process is not completely objective (van Teijlingen et al., 2024). That insight is the paper's strongest analytical point and would repay a fuller treatment.
How the paper sits in the wider literature
Empirical studies support several of the paper's claims and fill some of its gaps. Dowle (2022), using case study data from a UK research-intensive university and validation workshops with staff from other universities, found that progress monitoring can be an effective and supportive way of dealing with project and time-management problems, but that its effect depends on how reviews are perceived within doctoral researchers' social networks and on overcoming norms that discourage transparent reporting. This is close to van Teijlingen and colleagues' argument that the spirit in which a review is run matters as much as its rules.
Administrative procedures are not experienced in the same way by everyone. Mewburn et al. (2014) found that men and women at an Australian university reported qualitatively different encounters with progress reporting, even though the mechanism was meant to apply the same standards to all. Sillence (2023), interviewing assessors in the arts and humanities at a British university, highlighted how institutional, disciplinary and individual interpretations of criteria shape early-stage progress assessment, which matches the variation the reviewed paper describes.
The milestone also matters for identity. Heron et al. (2023) interviewed UK doctoral students who had recently passed confirmation and found that, for many, it was a catalyst for feeling like a researcher, through external validation, recognition and legitimacy. Read alongside research on doctorateness and threshold concepts (Trafford & Leshem, 2009; Kiley, 2009), this suggests that the transfer review can mark a genuine change in how candidates understand their work, not only a change in registration status.
Finally, the paper's recommendations for supervisors fit research showing that supervisors hold different conceptions of their role, from functional project management to enculturation and relationship development (Lee, 2008). A supervisor who sees the review as a box to tick will prepare a student very differently from one who sees it as part of enculturation into the discipline.
What it means for doctoral researchers
The paper's most practical message is to treat the regulations as a primary source. National reference points describe what a doctorate is (QAA, 2020), but the detail of progression is set locally. The table lists what to find out early; the questions are ours, built on the paper's recommendations.
| Question to check | Where to look | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| What is the milestone called and when is it due? | Research degree regulations; doctoral college handbook | Deadlines may fall earlier than expected for part-time or funded candidates |
| What must be submitted, and how long? | Faculty or school guidance | Expectations range from a short plan to a long report with results |
| Who assesses, and can supervisors attend or speak? | Regulations; ask the programme lead | Shapes how you prepare and who you should brief |
| What outcomes are possible? | Regulations | Knowing whether resubmission or MPhil registration are options reduces uncertainty |
| How and when is feedback given? | Guidance; previous candidates | Written feedback is the basis for your next steps |
Worked example (illustrative)
Consider a hypothetical second-year candidate in public health preparing for an 18-month confirmation review. Six months ahead, she reads the regulations and discovers that the panel includes an assessor from another discipline and that supervisors may observe but not speak. She therefore writes her report for an informed non-specialist, defining her key terms and justifying her mixed-methods design rather than assuming agreement. She agrees with both supervisors, in writing, that the report is ready to submit, which resolves a disagreement between them about the scope of the qualitative phase. She rehearses a ten-minute presentation with peers, prepares a realistic timeline to submission, and plans how to record the feedback she receives. None of these steps guarantees a pass, but each addresses a risk the reviewed paper identifies.
Common mistakes before a transfer viva
- Assuming the procedure is the same as at a previous university, or as a friend in another faculty describes.
- Submitting a report that one supervisor has not seen or approved.
- Presenting only a literature review, with no clear research questions, design or timeline.
- Writing for your supervisors rather than for assessors who may not share your specialism.
- Letting a supervisor or chair answer questions on your behalf, when the panel needs to hear your reasoning.
- Treating a request for revisions as failure rather than as feedback, and not asking for it in writing.
If an outcome is disappointing, speak to your supervisors and doctoral college about next steps, and use your university's wellbeing and student support services if the experience is affecting you. For the final examination, see our guidance on viva voce preparation; for how research questions develop during the doctorate, see our review of research question development.
Key takeaways
- van Teijlingen et al. (2024) show through four examples that UK progress and transfer vivas vary widely in name, timing, format and the role of supervisors.
- The paper is a reflective account without a stated method or outcome data, so its recommendations are well-informed proposals rather than tested findings.
- Empirical studies suggest progress reviews can help, but their effects depend on how they are run and perceived (Dowle, 2022; Mewburn et al., 2014; Sillence, 2023).
- Passing confirmation can strengthen a candidate's sense of being a researcher (Heron et al., 2023).
- The best preparation starts with your own university's regulations, an agreed report and practice explaining your plan to non-specialists.
