The paper under review
Halme et al. (2024) is a methodological article in the British Journal of Management, first published online in 2022 and in the January 2024 issue, and available open access. The authors observe that management scholars increasingly carry out qualitative research in low-income settings in emerging markets: large communities that often operate in the informal economy, cut across national boundaries and struggle to meet basic needs. Such settings, they argue, have received little separate methodological attention and are usually folded into the broader and more homogeneous category of emerging markets.
The article appeared in the same issue as an editorial essay calling for greater methodological pluralism in management research and for a reassessment of quality standards (Christofi et al., 2024). Read together, the two pieces show a field questioning whether one set of conventions can serve every research context.
The argument: rigour by convention and rigour within context
The central claim is that applying Western methodological conventions to low-income settings may produce decontextualised and distorted knowledge that does little for the communities studied. The authors call research that strictly follows methodological rules and steps, with limited adaptation to the setting, rigour by convention. As an alternative they propose rigour within context, which aims to reconcile two goals that can seem opposed: being rigorous and being contextualised. Researchers following this approach adapt their research to the setting even if that means departing from established conventions, and rigour is judged by the internal logic of the study rather than by external rules or templates that were not designed for these settings (Halme et al., 2024).
The authors organise the practical problem around localisation: of research activities and techniques, of results, and of the researcher. In each area, uncritical use of conventions can lower the quality of data, misrepresent informants' experience and narrow the theoretical contribution. They pay particular attention to the translators, intermediaries and gatekeepers through whom much fieldwork in these settings is done, and they close with recommendations for conducting contextualised research.
| Area | Typical convention | Contextualised alternative (illustrative) |
|---|---|---|
| Research activities and techniques | Recorded one-to-one interviews with written consent forms | Group or walking conversations, oral consent recorded by the researcher, notes where recording would alarm participants |
| Results | Themes abstracted from context to fit an existing theory | Findings reported with the local meanings, institutions and constraints that explain them |
| Researcher | Researcher presented as a detached outsider | Researcher's position, language, intermediaries and their influence reported and reflected on |
Strengths
- It names a neglected context. Separating low-income settings from emerging markets in general is a useful analytic move for management research on poverty, informality and inclusion.
- It reframes rigour. Treating rigour as fit between design and setting, rather than as compliance, connects the paper to a wider movement against templates in qualitative research (Pratt et al., 2022).
- It is grounded in experience. The authors write as field researchers, and their recommendations are practical rather than abstract.
- It takes intermediaries seriously. Interpreters and gatekeepers are treated as part of how data are produced, which many methods texts overlook.
- It speaks to editors and reviewers. By arguing about how rigour should be judged, it addresses the people who decide what is published, not only researchers.
Limitations and methodological issues
Who decides what counts as internal logic?
The strongest objection is practical. If rigour is judged by a study's internal logic, reviewers need a way to tell a reasoned adaptation from a convenient shortcut. Existing frameworks help. Lincoln and Guba (1985) already argued that naturalistic inquiry needs its own criteria of trustworthiness. Tracy (2010) offers eight broad markers, including rich rigour, sincerity and meaningful coherence, that do not depend on a particular template. JARS-Qual defines methodological integrity as fidelity to the subject matter and utility in achieving the study's goals, which closely matches the idea of rigour within context (Levitt et al., 2018). Linking the proposal explicitly to these criteria would make it easier to apply in review.
Conceptual rather than demonstrated
The paper argues from the literature and the authors' fieldwork rather than tracing a single project from design to publication. Readers therefore see adaptations in fragments, not as a coherent design that has passed peer review. A worked case would show how the approach handles the trade-offs it creates, for example between anonymity and the need to describe context richly.
Engagement with defenders of procedure
Procedural conventions exist partly to make qualitative work comparable and auditable. The debate on templates shows that their defenders and critics share the goal of trustworthy research and disagree on means (Pratt et al., 2022). A fuller dialogue with that position would strengthen the argument. Within international business, Welch et al. (2011) showed that case research can theorise in several legitimate ways, including contextualised explanation, which supports the authors' case for pluralism.
Translation and power
The emphasis on intermediaries could go further on translation itself. Temple and Young (2004) show that whether translation is acknowledged, and who does it, has epistemological consequences, because the translator helps construct the meaning that reaches the analysis. Decolonial scholars add that knowledge produced about the Global South through Northern frameworks carries a wider pattern of power (Quijano, 2007); the paper's critique of Western conventions sits close to this argument and could engage it directly.
How the paper fits the debate on qualitative quality
Management research has argued about qualitative rigour for decades. One response to reviewers' scepticism was the spread of recognisable templates, such as particular ways of building theory from multiple cases or of presenting data structures from interview coding. Templates made qualitative work easier to evaluate, but critics argue that they are often applied mechanically and that reviewers now expect them whether or not they suit the question (Pratt et al., 2022). The proposal of Halme et al. (2024) extends this critique to the setting: a template can be a poor fit not only for a research question but also for the place in which the research is done.
The paper also connects to work in international business on how theory is built from cases. Welch et al. (2011) distinguish several ways of theorising from case studies and argue that contextualised explanation, which treats context as part of the explanation rather than as noise to be controlled, has been under-used. Rigour within context can be read as the methodological counterpart of that position: if context explains, then data collection and analysis must be designed to capture it.
Finally, the paper raises a question about evaluation. If authors are allowed to depart from convention, reviewers and examiners need to know the reasons and the consequences. That shifts the burden onto transparent reporting. Frameworks that judge quality by coherence between aims, methods and setting, rather than by procedural checklists, provide a ready language for doing so (Tracy, 2010; Levitt et al., 2018).
Questions to ask when you use the paper
- Is your setting genuinely low-income or informal, or is "emerging market" being used as a loose label?
- Which conventional step would distort your data, and how do you know?
- What will you do instead, and how will a reader judge whether it worked?
- Which quality criteria will you ask examiners to apply?
What it means for a doctoral researcher
For a management doctorate in a low-income or informal setting, the paper gives permission and a vocabulary for adapting conventional methods, together with an obligation to explain every adaptation. Examiners will accept a departure from the textbook if you show what the conventional step would have distorted, what you did instead and how you checked the consequences. Discuss planned adaptations with your supervisor and ethics committee early, because some, such as oral consent or unrecorded interviews, need approval before fieldwork begins.
A worked walkthrough (hypothetical)
The following example is invented for teaching. A doctoral researcher studies how women's savings groups in an informal settlement make lending decisions.
- Access. A local non-governmental organisation introduces the researcher to group leaders. Because the organisation also funds some groups, she records how this may shape what members say and recruits some groups through other routes.
- Consent. Many members are uncomfortable signing forms, so the ethics application proposes oral consent, read in the local language and noted by the researcher, and explains why.
- Data collection. Group meetings are observed and members are interviewed in pairs, which they prefer to one-to-one interviews. Recording is used only where the group agrees; otherwise detailed notes are written the same day.
- Translation. A trained interpreter from a neighbouring community is used; difficult terms for money and obligation are discussed and kept in the original language in the analysis (Temple & Young, 2004).
- Analysis and checking. Emerging interpretations are discussed with two group leaders as a check on meaning, treated as additional data rather than proof (Birt et al., 2016).
- Reporting. The methods chapter lists each departure from convention, its reason and its likely effect, following the principle of methodological integrity (Levitt et al., 2018).
What to report and common mistakes
| Element | What to report |
|---|---|
| Setting | Economic, institutional and social features of the community, beyond the national label |
| Access | Intermediaries and gatekeepers, their interests and their likely influence |
| Language | Languages used, who translated, how key terms were handled |
| Adaptations | Each departure from standard procedure, why it was made and its consequences |
| Consent and protection | How consent was obtained and recorded, how participants were protected |
| Researcher | Position, relationships and reflexive decisions |
| Quality | Criteria used to judge rigour and how the study meets them |
Common mistakes
- Treating a whole country as the context and ignoring the specific community studied.
- Making adaptations silently, so that they look like errors.
- Leaving interpreters and intermediaries out of the methods section.
- Forcing data into a template-driven coding structure that strips out local meaning.
- Claiming rigour within context without stating the criteria by which it should be judged.
Key takeaways
- Halme et al. (2024) argue that strict adherence to Western conventions can distort qualitative knowledge of low-income settings.
- Rigour within context judges a study by its internal logic and fit to the setting rather than by templates.
- Established criteria such as trustworthiness, big-tent quality and methodological integrity can make that judgement workable (Lincoln & Guba, 1985; Tracy, 2010; Levitt et al., 2018).
- Interpreters, intermediaries and gatekeepers shape data and should be reported and reflected on (Temple & Young, 2004).
- Every departure from convention needs a stated reason and an assessment of its consequences.
